Skip to content
Families Advocating for Meaningful Education
  • About
  • Get Educated 
    • Get The Facts 
      • Indoctrination
      • Critical Race Theory
      • The 1619 Project & History
      • Comprehensive Sexuality Education
      • Woke Math and Science
      • Social Emotional Learning
      • Action Civics
    • Exposing Indoctrination 
      • Organization
      • Purveyors
      • Books
      • Woke School Districts
    • Consequences of Indoctrination
    • Woke Glossary
    • School Boards 
      • School Boards 101
      • Presenting at School Boards
      • Example Letters
      • Open Record Request 
        • Sample FOIA Letters
        • FOI Hotlines (External Links)
  • Resources 
    • Rights & Facts
    • Information by State
    • Alternative Curriculum
    • Example Letters
    • Example Petitions
    • Legislation 
      • Model Legislation
      • Legislation Tracking
    • Empower
    • Expose
    • Engage
  • Features 
    • Gender Ideology
    • Social Emotional Learning
    • Private Schools
  • Contact
Families Advocating for Meaningful Education
Menu Close
  • About
  • Get Educated 
    • Get The Facts 
      • Indoctrination
      • Critical Race Theory
      • The 1619 Project & History
      • Comprehensive Sexuality Education
      • Woke Math and Science
      • Social Emotional Learning
      • Action Civics
    • Exposing Indoctrination 
      • Organization
      • Purveyors
      • Books
      • Woke School Districts
    • Consequences of Indoctrination
    • Woke Glossary
    • School Boards 
      • School Boards 101
      • Presenting at School Boards
      • Example Letters
      • Open Record Request 
        • Sample FOIA Letters
        • FOI Hotlines (External Links)
  • Resources 
    • Rights & Facts
    • Information by State
    • Alternative Curriculum
    • Example Letters
    • Example Petitions
    • Legislation 
      • Model Legislation
      • Legislation Tracking
    • Empower
    • Expose
    • Engage
  • Features 
    • Gender Ideology
    • Social Emotional Learning
    • Private Schools
  • Contact

Signin

Lost your password?

Not Registered? Sign up

Recover Password

Already registered? Signin

New Signup

  • Date of birth

Already registered? Signin

Social Emotional Learning (SEL) 101

fsadmlgn June 10, 2022 Social Emotional - Resource 0 Comments

“Social and Emotional Learning.” It sounds so innocuous, so appropriate and positive. School officials and policy makers are asking: How could any parent oppose the development of social and emotional skills? But parents are growing more and more alarmed – and for very good reasons. 

Social Emotional Learning, often referred to as SEL, has changed over time. Originally, the goal of SEL was to promote morally neutral soft-skills such as self-awareness, self-management, empathy, and goal setting. 

In 2020, everything changed with the shift to “Transformative SEL.”

“Transformative SEL” is basically race and gender ideology embedded into what had previously been neutral student competencies.  “Self-Awareness” encompasses “identity,” with “identity” defined now through the lens of “intersectionality.”1 “Self-management” encompasses “agency,” with “agency” defined through “resistance” and “transformative/justice-oriented” citizenship.2 “Transformative SEL” embraces the pedagogical philosophy of “culturally relevant/responsive” practices, pioneered by professor Gloria Ladson-Billings, the woman who brought Critical Race Theory to K-12 education.3

One cannot have a working knowledge of SEL without understanding the importance of CASEL, the Collaborative for Academic, Social and Emotional Learning. CASEL is the single most important entity in the field of SEL and by 2020, they had completely embraced Transformative SEL.

“What these [SEL] programs do,” says Jennifer McWilliams, a former teacher and SEL expert, “is use innocuous language like ‘social emotional learning,’ that sounds nice, to cover the Trojan Horse that it is for bringing in the Critical Race Theory ideology, gender identity / sexual orientation [instruction], and social justice education.” 4

SEL proponents often disagree with this characterization. But parents need only look to CASEL’s website to see the evidence. For example, in its “Roadmap to Re-Opening,” CASEL defines “self-awareness” as “examining our implicit biases,” and “Self-management” as “practicing anti-racism.”5 CASEL’s former CEO, Karen Niemi, declared “we believe that our work in Social and Emotional Learning must actively contribute to anti-racism,” and that SEL can “help people move from anger, to agency, and then to action.”6

One can have an academic debate about whether it’s appropriate to equate “anti-racism” with “critical race theory.” But no less a prominent liberal intellectual than Yale’s David Bromwich has declared that “anti-racism” is an ideological doctrine.7 By positioning SEL as a champion of an ideological doctrine and a tool to channel “anger” into “activism,” CASEL has rendered its enterprise explicitly ideological, partisan, and political. As the SEL brand expands, some school districts are leveraging it to implement practices not explicitly endorsed by CASEL, such as gender identity and sexual orientation instruction in elementary schools. 8

But they say it’s “evidence-based”?

Don’t believe them. Those claims are greatly exaggerated and the rare evidence of positive outcomes was a result of the old version of SEL. On the contrary, there is anecdotal reason to believe that  this newer version of SEL is contributing to a decline in students’ social and emotional health. It’s too soon to know for sure. 

Other reasons to ask questions and stay vigilant: 

  • School surveys have become central to SEL implementation. These surveys ask students highly sensitive questions about their mood, their beliefs, their family, and even their sexuality.9 Parents are not always informed about the nature of these questions, nor do they have strong reason to trust that the answers will remain private. Earlier this year, hackers stole personal information of over 820,000 students in New York City Public Schools.10 If SEL encourages schools to create more robust and sensitive datasets on their students, we should expect further hacks and data privacy violations. 
  • SEL effectively asks teachers to act as therapists.11 Trained only with pop-psychology and one day professional development sessions, it encourages them to probe into students’ psyches, to uncover and address “trauma.” There is a reason why medical ethics prohibits the practice of therapy by unlicensed and untrained individuals. 

Important Voices

Journal of Free Black Thought

  1. https://casel.s3.us-east-2.amazonaws.com/CASEL-Gateway-Transformative-SEL-Toward-Service-of-Ed-Equity.pdf
  2. https://casel.s3.us-east-2.amazonaws.com/CASEL-Gateway-Transformative-SEL-Toward-Service-of-Ed-Equity.pdf
  3. https://www.unco.edu/education-behavioral-sciences/pdf/TowardaCRTEduca.pdf
  4. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FT6zxyEgmhE&t=68s
  5. https://casel.org/casel-gateway-sel-roadmap-for-reopening/
  6. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UPWrnBA2274
  7. https://www.thenation.com/article/culture/crt-debate-schools/
  8. https://defendinged.org/incidents/west-hartford-publishes-elementary-social-justice-lessons-standards-and-mentor-texts-transgender-content-introduced-in-kindergarten/
  9. https://www.aei.org/research-products/report/make-intrusive-school-surveys-opt-in-rather-than-opt-out/
  10. https://www.nydailynews.com/new-york/education/ny-hack-illuminate-online-gradebook-compromised-personal-data-20220325-ahy3b3b3t5cjzajau63muqcniq-story.html
  11. https://www.aei.org/research-products/report/the-unexamined-rise-of-therapeutic-education-how-social-emotional-learning-extends-k-12-educations-reach-into-students-lives-and-expands-teachers-roles/
About The Author

View all post by fsadmlgn | Website

Post navigation

Previous Previous post: National Association of Independent Schools (NAIS)
Next Next post: Curriculum Alternatives

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Latest Post

June 29, 2022

Social Emotional Learning Livestream
Read more

June 16, 2022

Catholic League president questions National Association of Independent Schools’ “queer-inclusive curriculum”
Read more

June 16, 2022

Moses Brown School unveils ‘Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion’ plan with ‘concept of intersectionality;’ separates children by race.
Read more

June 16, 2022

Loyola Academy H.S. assignment asks students to apologize for color of their skin
Read more

June 16, 2022

Columbus Academy refuses to share copies of its race-based curriculum with parents
Read more

June 16, 2022

The Mount Vernon School issued plan to introduce new initiatives steeped in critical race theory
Read more

June 16, 2022

Sandy Spring Friends School Blog Post Recommends “Summer Homework for White People”
Read more

June 16, 2022

The Frisch School injects politics into student yearbook
Read more

June 14, 2022

Brentwood School 8th grade test injects opinion into test on current events
Read more

June 14, 2022

The Brentwood School Sorts Students and Families by Race, Religious Ethnicity and Sexual Orientation
Read more

Get The Facts

Indoctrination
Critical Race Theory
The 1619 Project & History
Comprehensive Sexuality Education
Woke Math and Science
Social Emotional Learning
Action Civics

Resources

Rights & Facts
Information by State
Alternative Curriculum
Example Letters
Example Petitions

Quick Links

About Us
Contact Us
Donate

Follow us

Copyright © 2022. All Rights Reserved. Developed by Blaze.team